![]() Pate in reinstating similar religious discrimination claims by a Buddhist inmate in Cruz v. “Taking as true the allegations of the complaint, as they must be on a motion to dismiss, the complaint stated a cause of action and it was error to dismiss it,” the justices wrote. Court upheld prisoner's lawsuit, decided Bill of Rights applied to prisonersĬooper appealed to the Supreme Court, which reinstated his lawsuit in a short per curiam opinion. ![]() Circuit Court of Appeals rejected Cooper’s claims, holding that incarceration brings about the loss of many constitutional rights and privileges. He also claimed that prison officials had infringed on his First Amendment rights in denying him access to a Quran while allowing other inmates their religious texts. Pate, the Court examined the dismissal of the claims of an Illinois inmate, Thomas Cooper, who alleged that he had been denied permission to purchase Black Muslim publications. Prisoner claimed religious discrimination when denied access to Quran The courts previously had considered inmates little more than charges of the state and were reluctant to intervene in the management of prisons, even when egregious constitutional violations of prisoners' rights were alleged. 546 (1964), decided that the Bill of Rights applied inside prisons, and that, in this particular case, authorities had erred in denying religious publications and texts to an inmate. ![]() (AP Photo/Stephan Savoia, used with permission from the Associated Press) All who enter the makeshift mosque remove their shoes. Williams stands outside to greet late arriving inmate worshipers. Pate, the Court examined the dismissal of claims of an Illinois inmate and decided the Bill of Rights, including the First Amendment right of religious freedom, applied within prisons. Muslim inmate Todd Williams stands outside a room used as a mosque during Friday afternoon's weekly worship at Rikers Island prison, in New York's East River, March 11, 2005. Supreme Court had been reluctant to intervene in management of prisons, considering inmates charges of the state.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |